Pick a brand that names its leather. Full-grain leather wears in well, but...

https://post-wiki.win/index.php/Is_a_Monogrammed_Card_Case_a_Safe_Gift_for_Men%3F

Pick a brand that names its leather. Full-grain leather wears in well, but check the edge finish, too. Read the warranty before you buy. Adding initials? Check if they’re stamped, engraved, or printed, and where they’ll sit.